Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Discuss the themes of modernism in W. H. Auden’s poems titled ‘Lullaby’ and ‘The Unknown Citizen’.



Question: Discuss the themes of modernism in W. H. Auden’s poems titled ‘Lullaby’ and ‘The Unknown Citizen’.



            Answer: Like imagery and symbolism, a theme plays an important role in literary compositions. A theme is the central idea of a poem that a poet wants to convey to the readers. However, despite several other themes, the themes of modernism have been focused in ‘Lullaby’ and ‘The Unknown Citizen’ by W. H. Auden. The major themes noticeable here are: crisis in male-female relationship, sense of insecurity, fear of social insults, sense of guilt, identity crisis, lack of desire for a change in life, materialism, dehumanisation and the rest.



            Lullaby is one of the best lyrics of W. H. Auden. Here, the relationship between male and female is in crisis because it is not based on moral virtues rather dishonesty. So, the honesty of the modern is fleeting:



“...fidelity

On the stroke of midnight pass

Like vibrations of a bell,”



            Here, the sense of insecurity always haunts the lovers because at the crack of dawn they will be separated as they have little time to make love to each other since death will separate them soon. Just as every creation on earth is subject to death and decay, so their love will come to an end soon. The speaker always thinks of death and he understands that he has little time. Therefore, he wants to utilise his time by making love to his beloved without losing a fraction of a second. So the lover says:



“Beauty, midnight, vision dies:”



            It is noticeable here that a couple of lovebirds are involved in out of marriage relationship. Although the lover, at first, was afraid of insults of his beloved from society because of their illicit relationship but he, towards the end of the poem, comes to a realisation that only universal love and charity will protect them from the nightly insults.



            A sense of guilt is always chasing them but they are not worried about it. And they find their physical union as spiritual as a hermit’s communion with the Almighty, God. 



“Mortal, guilty, but to me

The entirely beautiful.”



            ‘The Unknown Citizen’ is another excellent poem by W. H. Auden because of its modern theme. Of all themes, identity crisis is one of the major ones of the poem. Here, an unnamed citizen is described. Actually, a person without a name signifies that he or she is an ordinary person in society. Even, on a monument, two initials of a name along with a numerical figure are used by the speaker to introduce him to the readers. It indicates that he is reduced to a mere name. Here, he can be identified with the unnamed typist girl and the three Thames’ girls in ‘The Waste Land’ by T.S. Eliot. Even the title of the poem reminds us of how much he is suffering from identity crisis.



“To JS/07/M 378;”



          Materialism is another important theme in the poem. In modern time, money is called the second god because here each and every thing is counted in terms of money although it is known that money, wealth and status cannot only bring happiness in life, people worship money more than any other thing in this materialistic world. In the same way, the unknown citizen is considered according to the amount of money and wealth he possesses and the things he does.



            Communication-gap occurs here. As a modern man, the citizen is known to all by the things he has. But, people do not know much about him. Outer look is more important to the modern people than honesty and an individual. They regard a person as happy by the outer appearance. They have almost forgotten that all that glitters is not gold. Therefore, towards the end of the poem, the speaker becomes surprised, when the question of the citizen’s happiness and freedom arises as:



“Had anything been wrong, we should certainly have heard.”



            The actual humanity of the deceased citizen in question is not important to the State. His thoughts, feelings, hopes, fears and goals are elided from the conversation. Statistics cannot convey a man’s inner state. However, the poem shows the poet’s profound concern for the modern world and its problems. As a keen observer of the contemporary scene, Auden, realises that the totalitarian socialist state would be no Utopia and that man would be reduced to the position of a cog in the wheel and to a routine as a slave. A citizen will have no scope to develop his initiative or to assert his individuality. He will be made to conform to the State in all things like the unknown citizen.



            Passivity is another theme found here. The citizen in the poem is not only ideal but also patriotic because he has done everything an ideal citizen should do. As he is described, he seems very submissive to the State. Such blind submission implies his passivity. His payment of taxes, his addition of five children to population, his service to the Greater Community, his reasonable public opinion and his active participation in the war bear the sign of patriotism. Such patriotism here indicates his passive submission to the State.



“When there was peace, he was for peace:”



            In conclusion, it is clear from the discussion above that both of the poems deal with the problems of modern people. For this reason, Auden is regarded as one of the distinguished poets of the 20th Century. Although Auden, like T.S. Eliot, tries to diagnose society with problems, he has not of that seriousness as T. S. Eliot has in his poems. 



Md. Saiful Alam
B. A. Honours and M. A. in English
Lecturer of English
Queen’s College, Dhaka

My affectionate Readers,
Please, never hesitate to comment because your comment inspired me much. Moreover, any correction or suggestion regarding my writings will be largely appreciated and valued and you can ask me any grammatical questions regarding English. I promise I would try my level best to assist you, all. Thank you very much.
        

No comments:

Post a Comment

English 1st Paper, Jashore Board, Set: A -2024 (Possible Answer Paper)

Learn English with fun!